Blog reaction to Google's pull out from China
The Atlantic's James Fallows, who has spent I believe the last three years living in and reporting on China, offers his thoughts on the news:
But there are also reasons to think that a difficult and unpleasant stage of China-U.S. and China-world relations lies ahead. This is so on the economic front, as warned about here nearly a year ago with later evidence here. It may prove to be so on the environmental front -- that is what the argument over China's role in Copenhagen is about. It is increasingly so on the political-liberties front, as witness Vaclav Havel's denunciation of the recent 11-year prison sentence for the man who is in many ways his Chinese counterpart, Liu Xiaobo. And if a major U.S. company -- indeed, Google has been ranked the #1 brand in the world -- has concluded that, in effect, it must break diplomatic relations with China because its policies are too repressive and intrusive to make peace with, that is a significant judgment.
Ryan Tate, however, smells something fishy:
The timing of Google's aversion to censorship is telling. As admitted in Drummond's post, Google has bowed to the censorious demands of the Chinese regime for years, reasoning (conveniently) that the Chinese people were better off with Google than without it; Google even allowed its own censors to be profiled in the New York Times.Only now, amid executive turnover at Google China and a continued failure to best their state-sponsored competitor there, and after Chinese hackers have endangered the company's interests globally, does Google get firm on the issue of human rights. It's a clever way to dress up a security breach â?? and an embarrassing attempt to partner with China's authoritarian leaders â?? as an act of nobility and courage.
It would be grievous indeed if Google is trying to turn an act of corporate CYA into an international rebuke of China. Even Hillary Clinton is weighing in on this now.
Meanwhile, the Daily Telegraph's Peter Foster reports from Beijing that many Chinese bloggers would be upset at the loss of Google.
(AP Photos)
